Real kitchen remodel • Cabinets purchased for my own project
CabinetSelect Review: My Quick Verdict
Yes — based on my actual order, I would buy from CabinetSelect again.
I used CabinetSelect to buy replacement 30-inch Shaker upper cabinets after the 42-inch uppers from my first online RTA cabinet order did not work for the finished layout I wanted in my 8-foot-ceiling kitchen.
What impressed me most was not simply the cabinets. CabinetSelect asked for my measurements and reviewed the layout before the replacement order was finalized. After already dealing with one cabinet-sizing mistake, that mattered.
- What I bought
- 30-inch Shaker upper cabinets for my kitchen remodel
- Why I switched suppliers
- The first supplier’s 42-inch uppers did not work for the proportions I wanted in this kitchen
- What mattered most
- Measurement review before ordering and cabinets that fit the intended layout
- Would I buy from CabinetSelect again?
- Yes, based on this purchase
This is not a catalog review or a review based on samples. I actually bought the replacement upper cabinets from CabinetSelect and installed them in the kitchen shown on this page.
Is CabinetSelect Legit?
Yes. CabinetSelect was legitimate in my experience. I placed a real cabinet order, provided measurements for the kitchen, received the replacement cabinets, and installed them in my home.
The cabinets shown in these photos are the cabinets from that order.
That does not mean every customer will have the same experience, and I would still verify every cabinet size before paying. But based on my own transaction, CabinetSelect delivered the cabinets I ordered and the replacements worked for the layout I was trying to complete.
Why I Ended Up Ordering From CabinetSelect
The project started with Natural Wood Shaker RTA cabinets from another online supplier — the company behind the order people search for as BuyWholesaleCabinets.com.
The base cabinets from that first order worked, so I kept them. The problem was the wall-cabinet portion of the order. I received 42-inch upper cabinets, while the finished layout I wanted called for 30-inch uppers.
A cabinet-size mistake becomes expensive after delivery. You may be dealing with freight, restocking charges, another order and project delays.
Because of that experience, I did not automatically reorder the uppers from the first supplier. I wanted the next cabinet list checked against the actual room before more cabinets were shipped.
Read my BuyWholesaleCabinets.com review and first-order experience
What Was Different About My CabinetSelect Order?
The biggest difference was that measurements became part of the ordering process.
CabinetSelect asked for the information needed to review the layout before the replacement order was finalized.
After already making one costly cabinet-order mistake, that mattered more to me than another attractive computer rendering.
The process felt focused on whether the cabinet sizes would actually work in the room rather than simply getting a cabinet list into the shopping cart.
CabinetSelect Cabinet Quality: What Did I Think?
My main concern with the second order was fit, but the cabinets also needed to look right next to the base cabinets I had already installed.
The replacement Shaker uppers worked with the kitchen design and gave me the finished proportions I wanted.
I am not using laboratory tests or pretending I have installed hundreds of CabinetSelect kitchens. My judgment is based on the cabinets I purchased, handled and installed in my own kitchen.
For this project, I was satisfied with the cabinets and would order from CabinetSelect again.
The Result That Mattered Most: The Cabinets Fit
The 30-inch upper cabinets fit the layout I was trying to finish.
That sounds simple, but after receiving cabinets that did not work for the intended layout on the first order, fit became the most important part of the second purchase.
Pretty renderings are easy. Cabinets fitting the actual room is what matters.
What I Liked About CabinetSelect
Measurements Were Part of the Process
I wanted the replacement cabinet sizes checked against the room before another order shipped.
The Replacement Cabinets Fit
The 30-inch upper cabinets worked for the finished proportions I wanted in this kitchen.
The Process Felt More Thorough
There seemed to be more attention on how the cabinet sizes would work in the kitchen rather than only the headline price.
It Reduced the Stress of Correcting the Project
I was already paying for the consequences of the first-order sizing problem. A more careful second ordering process had real value to me.
CabinetSelect Shipping and Ordering Experience
With online RTA cabinets, I think buyers sometimes focus too much on the price of the cabinets and not enough on what happens if something on the order is wrong.
Once cabinets are shipped, a mistake can involve freight, return shipping, restocking charges and delays.
That is why the ordering process mattered so much on my CabinetSelect purchase. I wanted the cabinet sizes reviewed before another pallet was on the way.
My takeaway is simple: with a large RTA cabinet order, the value of getting the list right can easily be greater than saving a few dollars on the initial quote.
What I Would Verify Before Any RTA Cabinet Order
Using two suppliers on one kitchen taught me that an RTA cabinet quote is not just a dollar amount. It is a construction list containing cabinet heights, widths, fillers, finished panels, corners and appliance clearances.
Verify ceiling height, walls, corners, soffits, windows, doors and appliance openings.
Do not assume that the drawing and the itemized cabinet list match what you intended.
This is the mistake that affected my project. Verify each wall cabinet before approving the order.
A missing filler or incorrect clearance can stop an installation even when the cabinets themselves are correct.
The cheapest quote can stop being cheap very quickly if part of the order has to be returned.
Treat them like construction documents. Compare the final order against them before approving payment.
See my full RTA cabinet buying checklist and kitchen research
CabinetSelect vs BuyWholesaleCabinets.com: My Experience
| My Experience | First Supplier / BuyWholesaleCabinets.com Order | CabinetSelect Replacement Order |
|---|---|---|
| What stayed in my kitchen | Base cabinets | 30-inch upper cabinets |
| Upper cabinet height | 42-inch uppers did not work for my intended layout | 30-inch uppers worked for the finished layout I wanted |
| Ordering lesson | I learned that I needed to verify the itemized cabinet list myself | Measurements were reviewed before the replacement order was finalized |
| Biggest financial lesson | Freight, returns and restocking matter after an ordering mistake | A fit review can be worth more than simply choosing the lowest quote |
| Would I use them for this same order again? | I would be much more cautious and verify every line | Yes, based on my replacement-cabinet experience |
Read the full BuyWholesaleCabinets.com review
Evidence From My First Cabinet Delivery
The original pallet really did include 42-inch wall cabinets. These are photographs from my project, not catalog images or manufacturer marketing photos.
Is CabinetSelect Worth It?
For my replacement order, yes.
The value was not simply getting another set of cabinets. The important part was getting cabinets that worked for the room after I had already experienced the cost and frustration of an incorrect cabinet-size decision.
I would still compare prices. I would still get another quote. And I would still check every cabinet dimension myself before approving an order.
But I would not automatically choose a cheaper cabinet quote if the more expensive supplier provided a better process for verifying the design.
Would I Order From CabinetSelect Again?
Yes, based on this purchase.
After the sizing problem with my first cabinet order, CabinetSelect asked for measurements, reviewed the replacement layout, and I ended up with upper cabinets that worked for my kitchen.
I would still verify every line of the order myself. No cabinet company removes that responsibility from the homeowner.
Who Should Consider CabinetSelect?
I would include CabinetSelect on the comparison list if you are shopping for online RTA cabinets and want the room measurements and cabinet layout to be part of the ordering discussion.
I think that becomes especially important when:
- you are remodeling an existing kitchen rather than starting with an empty room
- you have an 8-foot ceiling or other height constraints
- you are working around existing appliances
- fillers and corner clearances are tight
- you are mixing replacement cabinets into an existing layout
- return freight would make a mistake expensive
This review represents one real kitchen and one real CabinetSelect order. It is not a guarantee that every buyer will have the same experience.
Worth It Scout takeaway
My CabinetSelect order worked because fit became part of the purchase — not something I had to fix after another truck left.
I would use CabinetSelect again for this type of RTA cabinet order. I would also still check the itemized cabinet list myself before paying.
CabinetSelect Review FAQ
Is CabinetSelect legit?
Yes, based on my experience. I purchased replacement RTA kitchen cabinets from CabinetSelect, received the order and installed the cabinets shown in this review.
What cabinets did I buy from CabinetSelect?
I purchased 30-inch Shaker upper cabinets to replace 42-inch upper cabinets from my first RTA cabinet order.
Why did I choose 30-inch upper cabinets?
For my particular 8-foot-ceiling kitchen, 30-inch uppers gave me the finished proportions and layout I wanted. That does not mean 30-inch cabinets are automatically the right choice for every 8-foot kitchen.
Did CabinetSelect review my kitchen measurements?
Yes. Measurements were requested and used as part of reviewing the replacement cabinet layout before the order was finalized.
Would I buy CabinetSelect cabinets again?
Yes. Based on this order, I would use CabinetSelect again. I would still compare quotes and personally verify every cabinet dimension before approving the order.
Some Worth It Scout pages contain affiliate links. If you buy through one, Worth It Scout may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This CabinetSelect review is based on cabinets purchased for the kitchen shown in these photos.
Leave a Reply